CV CVNA Carvana Co. Loading... : Bullish and Bearish Analyst Opinions

Edwin Dorsey suggests the SEC's lack of FOIA response on Carvana likely means the investigation is ongoing, not concluded, casting doubt on positive resolution.

Campbell states he was short CVNA and is not short SMH, indicating a bearish past position on Carvana with no current SMH short.

The tweet reports that core CPI rose more than expected, with falling vehicle prices providing relief for CVNA and KMX, while SPY retains a Buy rating despite sticky inflation data.

Short on Carvana, no thesis

Reports Carvana record sales and revenue growth in Q1, no directional view.

CVNA is universally hated – “I fucking hate cvna”, “investigate CVNA”, “will end with multiple prison sentences”. The “profit of $2,785 per vehicle” comment is met with disbelief. Extreme retail disgust and fraud suspicions imply the stock is overvalued and due for a correction. With oil and yields rising, speculative names like CVNA are vulnerable. Short CVNA as a mean‑reversion play. The community’s negative sentiment acts as a contrarian signal for an eventual crash. Short squeezes are possible; the stock has defied bearish calls before. “No position just hate” shows some are already on sidelines.

Short car rental and Carvana overvalued

Self-RT naming $CVNA as the stock to short to hedge positions, with an Elliott-wave B-wave-up thesis preceding a move down — explicit shorting recommendation framed as his own call.

Speaker explicitly says 'we open shorts here' on $CVNA as a hedge after expected B wave upwards — explicit short position language with first-person 'we'.

Short reports have been released and insiders are actively selling the stock. Insider dumping combined with a deteriorating macroeconomic environment (high rates, struggling consumer) creates heavy downward pressure. Short CVNA, though with caution due to high volatility. High short interest could lead to violent short squeezes.

Current pressures on gross profit per unit are transient, implying margins will recover and the stock has upside potential.

The community is drawing direct parallels between SMCI's accounting practices and CVNA. With SMCI collapsing due to "cooked books," the market may start hunting for other companies with questionable accounting. CVNA is viewed as the next logical target for a massive repricing due to accounting skepticism. CVNA has a history of violent short squeezes.

Holds CVNA puts as part of a downside hedge book.

Active, long-running CVNA short; sees a weekly close below $300 confirming downside, target zero.

Carvana is a legacy short; author reduced position during a squeeze but remains short.

"Over 690,000 returns have claimed no tax on car loan interest." Making auto loan interest tax-deductible effectively lowers the true cost of financing a vehicle. This policy directly incentivizes consumers to take out auto loans and purchase new or used vehicles, providing a strong tailwind for auto manufacturers and auto retailers who have previously struggled with high interest rates. LONG. Automakers and used-car platforms will see a surge in demand as the tax code now subsidizes the cost of auto financing. Underlying vehicle prices remain too high, or broader macroeconomic weakness prevents consumers from taking on large debt obligations despite the tax incentive.

Reaffirms CVNA-to-zero short thesis: subprime auto lender hit by tightening private credit and rising unemployment in a risk-off environment.

Continues active CVNA short; expects it to reprice lower on deteriorating credit and rising unemployment.

Holds CVNA puts that are working as markets sell off; active bearish options position.

The author presents evidence of a Carvana customer's loan being held by Bridgecrest, a company owned by the CEO's father, directly contradicting the CFO's public statements. This alleged misrepresentation suggests potential accounting irregularities or a deliberate effort to obscure the true nature of its loan portfolio, which could lead to a loss of investor confidence and regulatory scrutiny if proven true. The author believes this is evidence of corporate malfeasance that has artificially inflated the stock price, making it a prime short target. The author explicitly states they are short via put options. The author's evidence is a single, anecdotal case which may not be representative of a systemic issue. The relationship between Carvana, DriveTime, and Bridgecrest is complex and may have legal structuring that technically avoids the "selling loans to related parties" definition. The market may disregard this information if it's already priced in or considered immaterial.

Speaker points out these names are "seeing a breakdown in the momentum" or "not working." Specifically mentions Expedia is "easily disrupted by AI." Unlike the "Halo" winners, these stocks are technically broken or facing structural threats (AI for Expedia), making them dangerous holds in a shaky discretionary environment. AVOID / SHORT. Unexpected resurgence in speculative growth/momentum factors.

The author suggests a contrarian bullish view on Carvana, implying that the prevailing negative market sentiment is overblown and the company's situation is better than perceived.

Carvana stock is down ~17%. The CEO acknowledged the company tried to "grow too fast," leading to "backsliding." This is a classic execution error. High-growth companies are punished severely when operational discipline fails. The admission of "backsliding" suggests structural issues in their scaling model. SHORT. Momentum has broken, and the market is repricing the execution risk. A sudden drop in interest rates could reignite demand for used car financing, squeezing shorts.

- CVNA: Missed EBITDA estimates; stock down ~22%. - CAR: Missed revenue, net loss, fleet costs issues. - CAKE: Comps down 2.2%, missed estimates. - LYV: Antitrust lawsuit advancing. The market is punishing execution errors severely. Carvana's miss combined with high short interest creates a liquidation dynamic. Avis signals weakness in the rental/auto market. Live Nation faces regulatory existential threats. SHORT/AVOID these names as momentum turns negative. Short squeezes in high-beta names like CVNA.

* Avis (CAR): Missed revenue, reported a net loss due to impairment, and gave full-year EBITDA guidance ($800M-$1B) below Street estimates. Stock down ~7.5%. * Carvana (CVNA): Missed EBITDA and Margin estimates (9.1% vs 10.4% expected). Stock down ~15%. Both companies operate in the auto/transport ecosystem and failed on profitability metrics. The market is currently punishing margin misses and weak guidance mercilessly. For CVNA specifically, high short interest combined with a fundamental miss suggests the "turnaround" narrative is broken, inviting fresh selling. SHORT (Fundamental Deterioration). A short squeeze in CVNA due to high short interest if meme-stock dynamics return.

There is a strong, recurring sentiment that Carvana ($CVNA) is a "scam company," a "dog shit company," and fundamentally overvalued. Multiple users with high upvotes announced they were buying puts (e.g., u/Lcc30: "Got 5k in cvna 320 puts," u/Afraid_Deal_4376 loading up on "80p leaps after the earnings"). The implied move for earnings was noted as 15.7%. The community's deep-seated negative perception of CVNA's business model and financial health creates a conviction that its earnings report will be poor, leading to a significant price drop. The high implied volatility is seen as an opportunity for puts to "print." The prevailing community view is that CVNA is fundamentally flawed and its stock is destined to fall post-earnings. A short position, primarily through puts, is the consensus trade to capitalize on the expected negative reaction. Several users warned that CVNA is the "cockroach of Wall Street" and notoriously volatile, capable of squeezing shorts (u/Afraid_Deal_4376, u/TelevisionCool2806). Others noted the stock might already be priced in and could trade flat (u/Rvin16), or that options premiums are outrageously expensive, requiring a massive move to be profitable (u/the_tailor). TICKER - DIRECTION

1. THE FACT: The tweet states, "That's a bummer. $CVNA was on the top of everyone's list to be included. Someone needs to tell the insider." This is in response to a link (not provided, but contextually related to index inclusion). 2. THE BRIDGE: The "bummer" and the implication that CVNA was expected for inclusion but seemingly wasn't (or won't be) suggests that a significant positive catalyst has been removed or will not materialize. Index inclusion often leads to a stock price boost. The failure to be included, especially when widely expected, can lead to disappointment and selling pressure. 3. THE VERDICT: $CVNA is unlikely to be included in a major index (like the S&P 500), which removes a significant expected positive catalyst and could lead to selling pressure.