Larry McDonald: Private Credit Is This Cycle's Subprime — And Retail Investors Are Holding the Bag

Watch on YouTube ↗  |  March 31, 2026 at 14:00  |  49:25  |  Julia LaRoche Show

Summary

  • Private credit is this cycle's subprime equivalent: opaque, over-leveraged, with bad marks (mark-to-myth), and already a crisis. Retail investors were sold quarterly liquidity on an inherently illiquid asset class.
  • The private credit crisis is causing a "truth bleed" similar to 2007-08; sell-side research initially called issues "idiosyncratic" but is now shifting, and insurance companies (e.g., Met Life) are potential bag holders.
  • Stagflation is the defining macro theme for 2026, driven by sticky energy inflation (due to Middle East supply chain damage) and an emerging economic slowdown (energy costs act as a ~1% tax on GDP).
  • The 60/40 portfolio is broken; the historical negative correlation between stocks and bonds has broken down since 2022, meaning both can sell off together in the current regime.
  • A "Great Migration" out of financial assets (paper certificates) and into hard assets (energy, copper, gold) and the companies that own them is underway, estimated to be only in the "second or third inning."
  • Money is rotating out of the Mag 7 (down 15%+, led by Meta and Nvidia) into industrials, materials, and energy stocks, which were only ~9% of the S&P but are now ~13%, mimicking the 1968-81 period.
  • Natural gas equities (e.g., FCG, TER) are a top multi-year bullish idea due to "trapped gas" in Canada/Texas and demand from relocating data centers facing NIMBY and cooling issues.
  • After a tourist-driven pullback, gold and silver miners are a buy near the 100-day moving average; household ownership of hard assets is still historically low (~1.25% vs. 3% in the 80s).
  • Made a first-ever Bitcoin purchase, citing a favorable Bitcoin-to-gold ratio (~13 vs. high 30s) and currency debasement themes, expressed via ETFs like IBIT for broad accessibility.
  • The UK (and France) is an under-the-radar systemic risk due to high energy costs hitting consumers, slowing growth, and challenging bond issuance amid large deficits.
  • The US fiscal picture is dire (6% deficits, 125% debt-to-GDP), leading to long-term dollar debasement, but the dollar remains the "cleanest dirty shirt" and will see counter-trend rallies during global flights to quality.
  • The AI/data center buildout is hitting cost overruns (energy, DRAM from Micron, Caterpillar shortages), crushing Mag 7 profit margins and slowing the investment boom.
Trade Ideas
Lawrence McDonald Founder of the Bear Traps Report, Former Lehman Brothers VP 3:12
Recommended a short on financials (XLF) due to exposure to private credit and disruption from AI/software companies, a "double whammy." Private credit is a brewing crisis with bad marks and liquidity gates. Financials hold this risk and are simultaneously facing disruptive tech pressures. Financials are underperforming the S&P by the most since the financial crisis, indicating the thesis is playing out. The sector is currently oversold, suggesting a potential tactical bounce.
Lawrence McDonald Founder of the Bear Traps Report, Former Lehman Brothers VP 6:15
Bullish on natural gas equities like FCG and TER due to "trapped gas" in Canada/Texas and the need to power/relocate data centers. High energy and memory costs are forcing a reevaluation of data center locations. Natural gas in areas with trapped supply is a cheap, strategic solution for this multi-year buildout. Natural gas equities are breaking out versus the S&P, have great valuations, and are poised for a "real great bull market" over the next five years. A severe economic slowdown reduces energy demand broadly.
Lawrence McDonald Founder of the Bear Traps Report, Former Lehman Brothers VP 16:13
Cites these companies as examples of those that own "lots of assets" and will benefit from the "Great Migration." In a stagflationary world, companies controlling hard assets (industrial, material, energy) historically outperform financial assets. Portfolio construction is shifting from the Mag 7 to these groups. These are direct plays on the multi-year rotation into hard assets, which is still in its early innings. A deep global recession crushes commodity demand despite sticky inflation.
Lawrence McDonald Founder of the Bear Traps Report, Former Lehman Brothers VP 22:24
Points to coal names being up 20-30% this year. Notes Dave Einhorn's Greenlight Capital has a top position in coal (e.g., Core Natural Resources). Demand is boosted by data center power needs and Middle East disruptions to LNG supply, making coal a more attractive global power source. The fundamental demand shift, combined with existing supply constraints, is driving outperformance. Accelerated global policy shifts away from fossil fuels, or a rapid resolution in the Middle East restoring LNG flow.
Lawrence McDonald Founder of the Bear Traps Report, Former Lehman Brothers VP 23:57
Sold gold/silver miner ETFs (GDX, SLV, SIL) in January and is now buying them back after a significant drawdown. The pullback flushed out "tourists" and weak hands. In a new bull market, buying near the 100-day moving average is a sound strategy, especially when ownership is still low historically. Miners have been hit by diesel costs, but underlying metal prices (gold/silver) remain profitable. The secular migration into hard assets supports higher prices. A sharp rise in real interest rates or a deflationary shock could pressure precious metals.
Lawrence McDonald Founder of the Bear Traps Report, Former Lehman Brothers VP 27:06
Made a first-ever Bitcoin purchase, citing a Bitcoin-to-gold ratio in the mid-to-low teens (from high 30s). The ratio suggests relative value. ETFs have democratized ownership, reducing concentration risk. The long-term thesis aligns with currency debasement and hard asset scarcity. Recommends taking advantage of the Bitcoin drawdown as part of the broader portfolio migration into scarce, non-sovereign assets. A major credit event could force liquidations from large holders, crushing the price despite improved ETF liquidity.
Lawrence McDonald Founder of the Bear Traps Report, Former Lehman Brothers VP 43:54
States insurers (e.g., Met Life) are the "ultimate bag holders" of private credit, having been hoodwinked by rating agencies and sell-side research. Mentions clients have been shorting them. Insurers reached for yield in opaque private credit, which is now revealing significant credit risk. This mirrors the 2008 dynamic where insurers held toxic rated securities. As private credit marks worsen and gates trap capital, insurers holding these assets will face severe losses and balance sheet stress. A government-backed bailout or facility stabilizes the private credit market before widespread insurer insolvency.
Up Next

This Julia LaRoche Show video, published March 31, 2026, features Lawrence McDonald discussing XLF, FCG, TER, BHP, FCX, KOL, GDX, SLV, SIL, BTC, KIE. 7 trade ideas extracted by AI with direction and confidence scoring.

Speakers: Lawrence McDonald  · Tickers: XLF, FCG, TER, BHP, FCX, KOL, GDX, SLV, SIL, BTC, KIE