The sell-the-rip vs. buy-the-dip debate
Speakers
Summary
- Jim Lebenthal ties the market bottom to whether geopolitical hostilities have peaked; if peak is in, bottom is in, but uncertainties persist with the Strait of Hormuz closure and Iran charging tolls.
- Kevin Simpson believes the market bottom is in, citing the S&P 500 firmly above its 200-day moving average as a positive technical signal and support.
- Kevin Simpson expects very strong earnings from megacap tech, specifically naming Microsoft and Google, contributing to a constructive market setup.
- Bill Baruch is bullish since the recent low, noting improved market pulse, Powell's stance against hiking on energy shocks, and S&P trading below long-run average at 19x earnings.
- Bill Baruch plays devil's advocate: the bar is high for upcoming earnings, and the second year of the presidential cycle may limit upside, with S&P potentially stalling near record highs.
- Oil prices are seen staying elevated (not returning to $50-$60/barrel soon) due to geopolitical tensions, impacting inflation and Fed policy.
- Inflation data shows sticky headline inflation from energy spikes but improving core components; the market is digesting this with mixed reactions in Treasury yields.
- Fed rate cut expectations are muted; some speakers doubt cuts this year due to inflation, while others think a cut is still possible if consumer data deteriorates.
- Cushions like fiscal stimulus, AI build-out, and a stable labor market support the economy, but volatility is expected from weekend geopolitical developments.
- Technical levels are watched closely, such as S&P June futures around 6800, with breaks below potentially signaling deterioration.
Trade Ideas
Kevin Simpson explicitly stated that "MEGACAP TECH EARNINGS ESPECIALLY LIKE THE MICROSOFT AND GOOGLE'S WILL BE VERY STRONG." Strong earnings from these companies are expected to contribute to a positive market setup, supported by technical factors like the S&P being above the 200-day moving average. LONG direction due to anticipated earnings strength driving stock performance, aligning with a bullish market view. Earnings disappointments or broader market deterioration from geopolitical tensions or inflation could negate the thesis.
Bill Baruch said, "I REMAIN VERY BULLISH AT THIS LEVEL," referencing improved market pulse, Powell's comments, and technical support. Market sentiment has shifted positively since the low, with the VIX hitting 30 indicating panic subsiding, and fundamentals like earnings growth and productivity supporting upside. LONG direction based on constructive setup, though tempered by high earnings expectations and presidential cycle dynamics. Geopolitical escalation (e.g., Strait of Hormuz issues), inflation persistence, or earnings misses could lead to a rollback.
Up Next
This CNBC video, published April 10, 2026, features Kevin Simpson, Bill Baruch discussing MSFT, GOOG, SPY. 2 trade ideas extracted by AI with direction and confidence scoring.
Speakers: Kevin Simpson, Bill Baruch · Tickers: MSFT, GOOG, SPY