Equity Analyst Delusions

Bob Elliott · Nonconsensus · March 31, 2026 at 10:25 · ⏱ 4 min read  | Read on Substack ↗
TLDR
The article criticizes equity strategists for calling a bottom in stocks based on surging earnings expectations, arguing that these expectations are inflated due to energy sector gains without corresponding downgrades in other sectors. This incongruence means the price-to-earnings ratio drop overstates the market's adjustment to the oil shock, and inter-market action suggests more sanguine expectations than strategists claim. • Equity strategists are predicting a stock market bottom, citing earnings acceleration and valuation drawdowns from the war. • Author contends that actual earnings are not growing as reported; rising estimates are from energy analysts updating quickly while others delay. • Intermarket analysis shows stock declines are driven by rising discount rates and a stronger US dollar, not cheap valuations. • Earnings expectations for 2026 and 2027 have surged post-war, particularly in energy and materials, but not in impacted sectors like discretionary. • This pattern differs from the 2022 oil shock where earnings expectations eventually fell across most sectors. • The PE ratio decline overstates the market's reaction, and inter-market signals indicate limited pricing of the oil shock's economic impact.
Full Analysis

{ "tldr": { "summary": "The article criticizes equity strategists for calling a bottom in stocks based on surging earnings expectations, arguing that these expectations are inflated due to energy sector gains without corresponding downgrades in other sectors. This incongruence means the price-to-earnings ratio drop overstates the market's adjustment to the oil shock, and inter-market action suggests more sanguine expectations than strategists claim.", "key_points": [ "Equity strategists are predicting a stock market bottom, citing earnings acceleration and valuation drawdowns from the war.", "Author contends that actual earnings are not growing as reported; rising estimates are from energy analysts updating quickly while others delay.", "Intermarket analysis shows stock declines are driven by rising discount rates and a stronger US dollar, not cheap valuations.", "Earnings expectations for 2026 and 2027 have surged post-war, particularly in energy and materials, but not in impacted sectors like discretionary.", "This pattern differs from the 2022 oil shock where earnings expectations eventually fell across most sectors.", "The PE ratio decline overstates the market's reaction, and inter-market signals indicate limited pricing of the oil shock's economic impact." ] }, "trade_ideas": [] }

Read time 4 min
Length 4,599 chars
Category finance
More from Nonconsensus