Microsoft is NOT a bargain right now

u/HatedMoats · Reddit — r/ValueInvesting · 13 апреля 2026, 12:52 · ⬆ 27 очк. · 💬 76 комментариев  | Открыть на Reddit ↗
AI-резюме
=== SUMMARY === - Post details a DCF valuation of Microsoft (MSFT), concluding the stock is trading near fair value, not as a significant bargain. - Author's thesis: MSFT is a wonderful business, but current valuation offers only a ~13.8% upside and a thin margin of safety, making it not a clear value play. Key concerns are high capex for AI buildout and uncertain monetization timing. - Quality assessment: Well-researched DD. The author provides a detailed, transparent DCF model with explicit assumptions and scenario analysis. === SENTIMENT === MIXED === TRADE IDEAS === MSFT - WATCH | confidence: 0.85 | sentiment: +0.3 Speaker: u/HatedMoats Thesis: 1. THE FACT: DCF model yields a base case fair value of $422.15 vs. current ~$371, implying limited upside and a sub-optimal margin of safety. 2. THE BRIDGE: The author, a current holder, would only add significantly to their position at a materially lower price, defining two specific accumulation levels. 3. THE VERDICT: MSFT is a hold for existing owners but not a compelling buy at current prices; it becomes a more attractive value purchase only on a pullback. 4. RISKS: AI monetization occurs faster/more profitably than modeled; capex efficiency improves; WACC declines due to sustained lower rates. Timeframe: medium-term Key Points: - Fair value ~$422, 14% upside - Accumulate below $358 - Load up near $335 - 67% of value in terminal - AI capex pressures margins === COMMENTS SUMMARY === Community reaction is skeptical and divided. Top comment mocks the analysis with a simplistic "it always goes up" take, while another agrees with the cautious stance but is even more bearish, citing aggressive AI spending and declining segments like Office and Gaming. No substantive counter-DCF models are presented.
Оценка 27
Комментарии 76
% апвоутов 64%
Полный текст поста
Идеи
u/HatedMoats Reddit r/ValueInvesting
DCF model yields a base case fair value of $422.15 vs. current ~$371, implying limited upside and a sub-optimal margin of safety. The author, a current holder, would only add significantly to their position at a materially lower price, defining two specific accumulation levels. MSFT is a hold for existing owners but not a compelling buy at current prices; it becomes a more attractive value purchase only on a pullback. AI monetization occurs faster/more profitably than modeled; capex efficiency improves; WACC declines due to sustained lower rates.
Ещё от Reddit — r/ValueInvesting

This Reddit post, published April 13, 2026, features u/HatedMoats discussing MSFT. 1 trade idea extracted by AI with direction and confidence scoring.

Speakers: u/HatedMoats  · Tickers: MSFT