Having a look at performance of stocks recommended as "favorite value stock" in a big thread 3 years ago

-NewYork- · 2026-07-17T10:52:09+00:00

=== SUMMARY === - The post reviews the performance of stocks recommended as "favorite value stock" in a Reddit thread from September 2023, comparing individual returns to the S&P 500 (+66.8%) and Dow Jones (+51.8%). - The author’s thesis is to quantify how well the crowd-sourced value picks performed over three years, highlighting wide dispersion from huge winners (Nvidia +364%, TSMC +152%) to deep losers (ARE -55%, Bayer -52%). - Quality assessment: This is retrospective data compilation, not original due diligence. It’s useful as a sentiment/crowd-bias gauge but is noise for forward-looking decisions. === SENTIMENT === MIXED === TRADE IDEAS === No actionable trade ideas in this post. The author provides only historical performance data without any recommendation or analysis of current valuation or catalysts. All tickers listed are past picks; no new trades are proposed or implied.

AI Summary

Summary

The post reviews the performance of stocks recommended as "favorite value stock" in a Reddit thread from September 2023, comparing individual returns to the S&P 500 (+66.8%) and Dow Jones (+51.8%).
The author’s thesis is to quantify how well the crowd-sourced value picks performed over three years, highlighting wide dispersion from huge winners (Nvidia +364%, TSMC +152%) to deep losers (ARE -55%, Bayer -52%).
Quality assessment: This is retrospective data compilation, not original due diligence. It’s useful as a sentiment/crowd-bias gauge but is noise for forward-looking decisions.

Score 32

Comments 14

Upvote % 100%

Summary

▶ Full Post Text

More from Reddit — r/ValueInvesting