A strict DCF of Nike (NKE): Is the Elliott Hill turnaround a Value Trap? My model says intrinsic value is $12.16.
u/Aulipe ·
Reddit — r/ValueInvesting
· April 20, 2026 at 18:53
· ⬆ 16 pts
· 💬 29 comments
| View on Reddit ↗
AI Summary
Summary
A Reddit user performs a discounted cash flow (DCF) valuation on Nike (NKE), concluding its intrinsic value is $12.16 per share, significantly below its current ~$46 price.
The author's thesis is that even with optimistic assumptions about a new CEO-led turnaround, the stock is grossly overvalued and may be a "value trap" as the market has priced in an unrealistic recovery.
Quality assessment: This is moderately well-researched due-diligence (DD). The author provides specific, transparent financial assumptions and a model, but it represents a single, highly punitive valuation scenario.
Score16
Comments29
Upvote %75%
▶ Full Post Text
With Nike bringing back Elliott Hill as CEO, the stock saw a relief rally and is hovering around $46. But as value investors, we have to separate brand nostalgia from the actual cash flows. I wanted to see if there is any Margin of Safety left, or if the market has already priced in a flawless turnaround.
I ran a strict DCF based on their most recent financial realities. Here is the breakdown of my assumptions:
**1. The FCF Baseline & Growth** Nike’s Unlevered Free Cash Flow has plummeted to roughly $1.04 Billion over the trailing twelve months due to inventory issues and wholesale channel decay. To be fair to the new CEO, I modeled a solid **6.0%** annual FCF growth rate for the next 5 years, assuming he successfully stops the bleeding to On Running and Hoka.
**2. The WACC (Discount Rate)** I used a strict WACC calculation based on their actual capital structure:
* Risk-Free Rate: 4.5%
* Beta: 1.32
* Debt-to-Capital: 10%
* **Calculated WACC: 10.63%**
**3. Terminal Value** Nike is a mature behemoth in a highly saturated market. I used a Perpetual Growth Rate of **2.5%** for the terminal value, matching long-term inflation.
**The Math & The Verdict:** Discounting my 5-year recovery cash flows ($1.04B growing at 6%) and the terminal value back to present day, I arrive at a base-case intrinsic value of **$12.16 per share**.
*(I’ve attached a screenshot of my exact model inputs and projected cash flows below).*
Even if I assume they magically return to their 2021 peak margins tomorrow, it is incredibly difficult to justify the current $46 price tag mathematically without assuming an unrealistic perpetual growth rate.
Am I being way too punitive with my 10.63% discount rate, or is NKE a massive value trap right now? Would love to hear where the bulls think my math is wrong.
Analysis Screenshot Link: [https://imgur.com/a/dH4waDf](https://imgur.com/a/dH4waDf)
A strict DCF model, using a 10.63% WACC and a recovery growth rate, yields an intrinsic value of $12.16 per share, ~74% below the current market price. This massive valuation gap suggests the market is pricing in a flawless and rapid turnaround under new CEO Elliott Hill, which the author's analysis deems mathematically unjustifiable. The stock is a potential value trap (overvalued based on nostalgia, not fundamentals), creating an opportunity to short or avoid. The new CEO executes a turnaround faster/better than modeled; the author's WACC or growth assumptions are too severe; brand strength drives higher sustainable margins than projected.