I’m unable to pick stocks that go up over time

Summary

• The author laments an inability to pick stocks that appreciate over a 2-year horizon, despite 13 years of trading experience.
• They propose a simple thesis: companies with steady positive net income bought at cheap valuations (e.g., LULU at PE 9, CHTR at PE 4) should rise over time.
• The post is a frustration-driven question rather than a researched analysis; it lacks specific data, catalysts, or a clear investment framework beyond basic value metrics.

SENTIMENT

NEUTRAL

TRADE IDEAS

No actionable trade ideas in this post. The author expresses confusion and does not advocate a position, nor provide enough conviction or analysis to justify a directional trade. The examples (LULU, CHTR) are cited only to illustrate a personal failure, not as actionable picks.

COMMENTS SUMMARY

Top comments overwhelmingly advise the author to abandon active stock picking and switch to index funds (e.g., SPY), citing the lengthy unsuccessful track record and the existence of a prolonged bull market. One comment sarcastically notes that value investors in this sub “catch falling knives,” implying the author’s value-based approach may be timing the market poorly. No community member provides counter-arguments or additional data supporting LULU or CHTR.