Why does this sub not buy stocks that are going up?

Top-Sir-1215 · 2026-06-11T22:33:29+00:00

=== SUMMARY === - The post criticizes r/ValueInvesting for ignoring stocks that are rising, implying the sub only focuses on declining or undervalued names. - Author suggests that the sub’s bias toward “losers” may be driven by bots or groupthink rather than sound strategy. - The thesis is a meta-critique of value investing dogma, not a specific stock recommendation. - Quality assessment: This is low-effort speculation / opinion, not a well-researched DD. No data, no ticker, no analysis. === SENTIMENT === NEUTRAL === TRADE IDEAS === No actionable trade ideas in this post. === COMMENTS SUMMARY === Top comments defend value investing by noting the sub’s focus on buying when stocks are cheap (e.g., Google was discussed heavily as it rose from $150–200). Others dismiss the sub as “a loser sub” too afraid to chase and too proud to index, while a third commenter points out that stocks like Google, UNH, AMD, and Amazon were widely discussed when they were down but are now ignored after rallying — a reminder of recency bias. No specific counter-trade or new data is provided.

u/Top-Sir-1215 · Reddit — r/ValueInvesting · June 11, 2026 at 22:33 · ⬆ 24 pts · 💬 92 comments | View on Reddit ↗

AI Summary

Summary

The post criticizes r/ValueInvesting for ignoring stocks that are rising, implying the sub only focuses on declining or undervalued names.
Author suggests that the sub’s bias toward “losers” may be driven by bots or groupthink rather than sound strategy.
The thesis is a meta-critique of value investing dogma, not a specific stock recommendation.
Quality assessment: This is low-effort speculation / opinion, not a well-researched DD. No data, no ticker, no analysis.

Score 24

Comments 92

Upvote % 72%

Why does this sub not buy stocks that are going up?

Summary

More from Reddit — r/ValueInvesting