Great opportunity to SHORT SpaceX now that the S&P has refused to break its rules to force index investors into this garbage stock. Who is on Team SHORT?

UnlikelyAdventurer · 2026-06-08T20:57:15+00:00

=== SUMMARY === - The author argues that SpaceX is a heavily overvalued "garbage stock" with a P/E of 135, a $1.5T asking price, and multiple red flags (erratic CEO, xAI threat, government dependency, April Fool’s filing). - They propose shorting SpaceX from $135 down to $80, citing the S&P 500’s refusal to waive entry rules for unprofitable AI/fintech companies as a catalyst. - Quality assessment: Noise – the post is emotionally charged, lacks fundamental data, and SpaceX is a private company without a publicly tradeable short vehicle. === SENTIMENT === BEARISH === TRADE IDEAS === No actionable trade ideas in this post. SpaceX is a private company with no public ticker symbol, making a direct short trade impossible. The post also fails to specify any tradeable proxy (e.g., TSLA, SPCE) that would allow implementation. === COMMENTS SUMMARY === Community sentiment is overwhelmingly negative toward the short thesis. Top comments highlight the risk of shorting a billionaire with a cult following (u/eapnon: “Elon Musk can stay rich longer than I can stay solvent”), the futility of betting against irrational momentum (u/AntiqueProfessor5134: “I’ve thought Tesla would go down for years”), and the lack of a concrete shorting mechanism (u/ebikr: “Borrowing the stock will be very expensive”). Many users dismiss the post as emotional and lacking objective analysis.

u/UnlikelyAdventurer · Reddit — r/investing · June 08, 2026 at 20:57 · ⬆ 417 pts · 💬 269 comments | View on Reddit ↗

AI Summary

Summary

The author argues that SpaceX is a heavily overvalued "garbage stock" with a P/E of 135, a $1.5T asking price, and multiple red flags (erratic CEO, xAI threat, government dependency, April Fool’s filing).
They propose shorting SpaceX from $135 down to $80, citing the S&P 500’s refusal to waive entry rules for unprofitable AI/fintech companies as a catalyst.
Quality assessment: Noise – the post is emotionally charged, lacks fundamental data, and SpaceX is a private company without a publicly tradeable short vehicle.

Score 417

Comments 269

Upvote % 71%

Great opportunity to SHORT SpaceX now that the S&P has refused to break its rules to force index investors into this garbage stock. Who is on Team SHORT?

Summary

▶ Full Post Text

More from Reddit — r/investing

Great opportunity to SHORT SpaceX now that the S&amp;P has refused to break its rules to force index investors into this garbage stock. Who is on Team SHORT?

Summary

▶ Full Post Text

More from Reddit — r/investing

Great opportunity to SHORT SpaceX now that the S&P has refused to break its rules to force index investors into this garbage stock. Who is on Team SHORT?