Am I a bag holder?

cra676 · 2026-05-13T23:48:51+00:00

=== SUMMARY === - The author bought PayPal (PYPL) at ~$63 in Sep 2025, following a stock pick by Tom Hayes, and is now frustrated by poor price action. - They observe that positive news fails to move the stock while negative news causes outsized drops, leading to doubts about being a bag holder. - The thesis is superficial (relying on a single influencer) with no fundamental analysis; the post is a plea for advice rather than a researched DD. **Quality assessment**: Noise / speculative complaint. No data or valuation work presented. === SENTIMENT === BEARISH === TRADE IDEAS === PYPL - WATCH | confidence: 0.55 | sentiment: -0.30 Speaker: u/cra676 Thesis: 1. THE FACT: The author holds PYPL at $63 avg cost and notes that good news is ignored while bad news is amplified. 2. THE BRIDGE: This divergence suggests weak market conviction or structural selling, creating a potential for further downside or a sudden mean-reversion if sentiment shifts. 3. THE VERDICT: No clear directional call from the post; the author is undecided, so the actionable stance is to watch for a catalyst (earnings, macro shift) before taking a position. 4. RISKS: Continued underperformance due to competitive pressures (e.g., Block, Stripe) or macro headwinds; could drop below $50 if sentiment worsens. Timeframe: medium-term Key Points: - Avg cost $63, no catalyst in sight - Good news ignored, bad news double-hit - High uncertainty, avoid active entry - Wait for earnings or sentiment shift - Potential bag holder risk if hold **Note**: No actionable long/short trade ideas. The post is a reflection of confusion, not a trade signal. The WATCH rating reflects the author’s indecision and the stock’s current neutral-to-bearish technical setup.

u/cra676 · Reddit — r/ValueInvesting · May 13, 2026 at 23:48 · ⬆ 16 pts · 💬 42 comments | View on Reddit ↗

AI Summary

Summary

The author bought PayPal (PYPL) at ~$63 in Sep 2025, following a stock pick by Tom Hayes, and is now frustrated by poor price action.
They observe that positive news fails to move the stock while negative news causes outsized drops, leading to doubts about being a bag holder.
The thesis is superficial (relying on a single influencer) with no fundamental analysis; the post is a plea for advice rather than a researched DD.

Quality assessment: Noise / speculative complaint. No data or valuation work presented.

Score 16

Comments 42

Upvote % 100%

More from Reddit — r/ValueInvesting

Thoughts on this article? "Micron Technology Stock Will Skyrocket to $2,000 in 1 Year"

May 13, 22:43

Insider Purchase: Chief Executive Officer of $KHC Buys 213,106 Shares

May 13, 21:26

It’s impressive how MSFT goes down regardless what happens

May 13, 20:22

everything is at all time highs except microsoft… is msft about to sinkhole?

May 13, 19:26

AI adoption in white-collar work will be slower / messier than people think

May 13, 17:12