Buzzberg Cup Bracket locked

MU at $746, 120% YTD, where does the margin of safety actually sit on memory right now?

u/Leading-Equal204 · Reddit — r/ValueInvesting · May 11, 2026 at 04:19 · ⬆ 25 pts · 💬 33 comments  | View on Reddit ↗
AI Summary

Summary

  • Post analyzes Micron (MU) after 120% YTD rally, questioning the margin of safety given historical cyclicality and elevated valuation (22x forward earnings vs 8-12x peak).
  • Author is conflicted: acknowledges strong HBM demand and multi-year bookings from hyperscalers but fears AI capex repricing and lack of room for execution error.
  • Quality assessment: Well-reasoned, data-supported analysis blending cyclical history with current AI thesis. Not a formal DD but thoughtful, skeptical contrarian take.
Score 25
Comments 33
Upvote % 84%
Full Post Text
Ideas
u/Leading-Equal204 Reddit r/ValueInvesting
MU trades at 22x forward earnings vs historical peak of 8-12x; upside depends on perfect HBM4/5 execution and sustained $400B+ hyperscaler capex. Historically, memory cyclicals compress multiples when demand normalizes. The current risk/reward skews negative even if the bull case partially materializes. No clear edge to chase gains; low margin of safety suggests avoiding new longs and waiting for a better entry or clearer cycle signal. AI demand structurally alters memory cyclicality (bull); HBM wins could still drive earnings growth higher than consensus (bull); author admits bias from missing prior rally.
More from Reddit — r/ValueInvesting

This Reddit post, published May 11, 2026, features u/Leading-Equal204 discussing MU. 1 trade idea extracted by AI with direction and confidence scoring.

Speakers: u/Leading-Equal204  · Tickers: MU