u/goxpro1 ·
Reddit — r/ValueInvesting
· April 30, 2026 at 02:56
· ⬆ 28 pts
· 💬 48 comments
| View on Reddit ↗
AI Summary
Summary
The author criticizes frequent trading in r/ValueInvesting, advocating for a buy-and-hold strategy, citing personal success with Google (now ~$380) and SanDisk (implied later acquired by Western Digital).
Thesis: Long-term holding of quality companies (e.g., Google) outperforms short-term profit-taking; investors should ignore near-term volatility and hold until retirement.
Quality assessment: Noise/speculation – anecdotal, no fundamental analysis or data, more of a philosophical rant than researched DD.
Score28
Comments48
Upvote %72%
▶ Full Post Text
Why does everyone love to sell and buy every day? I remember when this sub was obsessed with Google, the second it hit 220 per share all I saw was people talking about taking profit... At 200 dollars per share... Now Google is 380 per share and will continue to go up for the next decade at least. The fact people love to day trade in a value investing subreddit is absolutely insane... The reality is you and I have no clue what is going to happen in the market, but people need to stop selling and buying. Just buy and HOLD. I'm still holding on to the Sandisk stock I bought at 50 dollars per share while everyone told me to sell at 300 a share now it's over 1000 dollars and everyone wants to buy at 1k per share... By the way I am not selling any of it, going to hold it until retirement since its all in retirement accounts and my work allows me to buy individual stocks in my 401k.
Google’s price rose from ~$220/share to ~$380/share, and the author believes it will continue climbing for at least another decade based on personal holding experience. The author’s conviction that selling early misses outsized gains suggests a buy-and-hold opportunity, especially if other investors follow the same pattern. Long-term buy-and-hold in GOOGL, with no intent to sell, leveraging the market’s tendency to reward patient investors. No fundamental valuation provided; Google could face antitrust, competition from AI, or regulatory headwinds that undermine growth.