It’s Not “Unusual” for the Market to Go Up on Bad News
u/OkBowls ·
Reddit — r/ValueInvesting
· April 07, 2026 at 12:38
· ⬆ 18 pts
· 💬 8 comments
| View on Reddit ↗
AI Summary
Summary
The post is a critique of retail investors overreacting to short-term market movements and daily news headlines, especially during a downturn.
The author's thesis is that market bounces on "bad news" are normal due to factors like institutional information advantage, short covering, forward-looking pricing, and the multifaceted nature of market drivers.
Quality assessment: This is speculative market commentary/perspective, not well-researched DD. It offers general principles of market psychology rather than data-driven analysis on specific securities.
Score18
Comments8
Upvote %91%
▶ Full Post Text
It’s exhausting seeing the same posts flood this sub.
“WHY ARE PEOPLE BUYING WITH THE STRAIGHT STILL CLOSED?” “HOW COME THE PREMARKET IS UP ON BAD NEWS?” “HOW COULD IT POSSIBLY BE A GREEN DAY???”
A few people on this sub need a serious dose of perspective.
**1.** Just zoom out. A +1% daily bounce after a -8% slow monthly bleed is hardly newsworthy. It certainly isn’t worth overreacting to.
**2.** You and I don’t have all the info. Even a first year analyst with a Bloomberg Terminal is working with VASTLY better data than us. If institutions are buying, maybe consider that their calculus is better informed and more experienced.
**3.** If you’re not familiar with short cover mechanics, you need to be. Any trader should be expecting and planning for “irrational” green days. It’s not abnormal, it’s not shocking.
**4.** Missing market psychology is real. The market is forward-looking, we’re all playing the probabilities. Not all headlines are catalysts because - even if we didn’t have the fine details - the threat of them was priced in weeks ago.
**5.** A war or a correction doesn’t mean the market drops every single day - that has never been the case. The Strait is the biggest macro story since the tariffs, but it’s not everything. Even in a correction, you’ll have other currents. The Wall Street Journal has fifty stories, don’t expecting the S&P to only mirror the front page.
Just…consider that we’re not all omnipresent Warren Buffets. We don’t know everything. Sometimes the market isn’t the idiot, sometimes it’s the guy trading on an app (me).