$WU - Western Union. A cigar butt thesis... priced like a tobacco stock without the cancer.

u/Christs_Hairy_Bottom · Reddit — r/ValueInvesting · February 03, 2026 at 14:35 · ⬆ 11 pts · 💬 25 comments  | View on Reddit ↗
AI Summary

Original Reddit post

Author presents a long cigar-butt thesis on Western Union, citing a 10%+ dividend yield, large buyback, cheap cash-flow valuation, and overstated risks.

WU — LONG Author presents a long 'cigar butt' thesis on Western Union, arguing the beaten-down stock has a 10%+ dividend yield, a $1B buyback program equal to 33% of shares, and >17% net annual capital return to shareholders. The causal mechanism is that despite digital competition and revenue/profit declines, WU's scale and universal remittance network in Africa, South America, the Middle East, and India should keep generating cash, with conservative cash-flow valuation suggesting at least $15/share fair value and ~50% upside plus dividends and buybacks. The main stated risk is the debt situation, which the author calls more concerning but potentially solvable if management diverts some dividend cash to debt reduction; other cited risks (digital competition, Trump crackdown on illegal immigration, revenue declines) are viewed as overblown. Time horizon is long term, with the author referencing the company potentially dying 20 years from now.

This is a cash harvesting cigar butt thesis with suggested 50% upside + massive dividends and buybacks.

Score 11
Comments 25
Full Post Text
Ideas
u/Christs_Hairy_Bottom Reddit r/ValueInvesting
Cigar butt long WU: dividends, buybacks, $15 fair value
Author presents a long 'cigar butt' thesis on Western Union, arguing the beaten-down stock has a 10%+ dividend yield, a $1B buyback program equal to 33% of shares, and >17% net annual capital return to shareholders. The causal mechanism is that despite digital competition and revenue/profit declines, WU's scale and universal remittance network in Africa, South America, the Middle East, and India should keep generating cash, with conservative cash-flow valuation suggesting at least $15/share fair value and ~50% upside plus dividends and buybacks. The main stated risk is the debt situation, which the author calls more concerning but potentially solvable if management diverts some dividend cash to debt reduction; other cited risks (digital competition, Trump crackdown on illegal immigration, revenue declines) are viewed as overblown. Time horizon is long term, with the author referencing the company potentially dying 20 years from now.
More from Reddit — r/ValueInvesting

This Reddit post, published February 03, 2026, features u/Christs_Hairy_Bottom discussing WU. 1 trade idea extracted by AI with direction and confidence scoring.

Speakers: u/Christs_Hairy_Bottom  · Tickers: WU