4th Quarter, year end earnings is upon us. This is the Super bowl, we are estimated to earn 270 a share for 2025 on SP500, Some tools to help fellow traders, what to do with my 33 bags!?

u/UltimateTraders · Reddit — r/smallstreetbets · January 17, 2026 at 14:17 · ⬆ 1 pts  | View on Reddit ↗
AI Summary

Original Reddit post

Author argues the S&P 500 is inflated at ~26x earnings and is holding cash while waiting for more fair value, using Q4/year-end earnings and 2026 EPS estimates as the key catalyst.

SPY — AVOID Author argues the S&P 500 is inflated at about 26x earnings and says historical multiples imply fair value below 21x, so he is holding a lot of cash instead of broad index exposure. He calculates that if 2026 earnings grow 10% to 297 and deserve 21x, the index would be 6,237, while 5% growth and 20x would be 5,670, making Q4/year-end earnings season the critical catalyst. He cautions this does not mean he predicts a crash or fall.

Personally, I believe the market is inflated and should never trade beyond 21x, that doesn’t mean we will crash, fall or even that I believe we will crash or fall, but I am in a lot of cash until the market moves to more fair value….

Score 1
Full Post Text
Ideas
u/UltimateTraders Reddit r/smallstreetbets
S&P 500 inflated at 26x; holding cash
Author argues the S&P 500 is inflated at about 26x earnings and says historical multiples imply fair value below 21x, so he is holding a lot of cash instead of broad index exposure. He calculates that if 2026 earnings grow 10% to 297 and deserve 21x, the index would be 6,237, while 5% growth and 20x would be 5,670, making Q4/year-end earnings season the critical catalyst. He cautions this does not mean he predicts a crash or fall.
More from Reddit — r/smallstreetbets

This Reddit post, published January 17, 2026, features u/UltimateTraders discussing SPY. 1 trade idea extracted by AI with direction and confidence scoring.

Speakers: u/UltimateTraders  · Tickers: SPY