Sanity check from value investors: would this be useful or just more noise?

I’m a DIY, value-oriented investor with a full-time job, and before spending real time building anything, I want honest feedback from people who actually invest this way. One thing I’ve struggled with is finding high-signal, long-term discussion. Many investing forums (even those claiming to be “long-term”) drift toward short-term price moves, headlines, or shallow takes that aren’t grounded in valuation. The idea I’m pressure-testing is a small, moderated forum where investors post value-based investment write-ups (not trade ideas), with an expectation that posts clearly cover: • valuation approach and key assumptions • downside risks and what would invalidate the thesis • intended time horizon (mid- to long-term) • why the idea fits within a broader portfolio The target user is a busy investor who wants idea generation and perspective without day-trading noise, and who values discipline over activity. My questions: • Would you personally read or contribute to something like this? • What would make it genuinely useful vs. something you’d quickly ignore? If this sounds interesting and you’d be open to a low-key follow-up when/if there’s something concrete to look at, feel free to DM me an email. No selling — I’m just trying to see if there’s real interest beyond my own bias. I’m very open to being told this is a bad idea. Blunt feedback is appreciated.