u/FederalPermission261

Reddit r/ValueInvesting
· tracked since Jun 2026
Calls 1 1 Posts tracked · 0.1/day
Calls
7d 0
30d 1
90d 1
Best Calls
VITL long +0.4%
Worst Calls
No live losers yet
Most Mentioned
VITL ×1
Recent Calls
VITL long 2 weeks ago
Win Rate 100% Long 1 Short 0
Win Rate
7d 100%
30d —
90d —
Average Return +0.4% Long Return +0.4% Short Return -
Average Return
7d +5.7%
30d —
90d —
Result
Result
Sort
Theme Stance
Ticker
Side
Mentions
Opened
Entry
P&L
Thesis
Theme
Source
VITL Vital Fa... Vital Farms, Inc.
Long
Jun 06
$10.04
+0.4%
VITL revenue $759mm, 47% ROIC, stock down 80%; DCF yields $19.45 intrinsic value vs. $10 market price; insiders bought at $18–20; $80mm buyback on $440mm market cap. Market overreacted to cyclical wholesale egg price crash (from $8 to $0.21/dozen) and near-zero 2026 EBITDA. Margins expected to recover in FY27 (4% EBIT), and terminal margin of 8.6% is below past peaks – creating significant upside once earnings normalize. Long VITL as a cyclical value play with brand moat and capital returns, betting on margin recovery and/or multiple expansion as the market reprices the stock. Cal-Maine’s $400mm specialty egg acquisition could commoditize pasture-raised eggs, compressing VITL’s terminal margins below model. If egg wholesale prices stay low or brand loyalty erodes, intrinsic value could fall below $8 (bear case).
VITL revenue $759mm, 47% ROIC, stock down 80%; DCF yields $19.45 intrinsic value vs. $10 market price; insiders bought at $18–20; $80mm buyback on $440mm market cap. Market overreacted to cyclical wholesale egg price crash (from $8 to $0.21/dozen) and near-zero 2026 EBITDA. Margins expected to recover in FY27 (4% EBIT), and terminal margin of 8.6% is below past peaks – creating significant upside once earnings normalize. Long VITL as a cyclical value play with brand moat and capital returns, betting on margin recovery and/or multiple expansion as the market reprices the stock. Cal-Maine’s $400mm specialty egg acquisition could commoditize pasture-raised eggs, compressing VITL’s terminal margins below model. If egg wholesale prices stay low or brand loyalty erodes, intrinsic value could fall below $8 (bear case).
Consumer
REDDIT
Showing 1 of 1 picks · sorted by mentions

u/FederalPermission261 has 1 trade idea tracked on Buzzberg across 1 ticker since June 2026. Most covered: VITL.